Indonesia Food Watch Called Coordinating Minister for Darmin Alone to Food Data

By : Wiyanto Dan Aldo Bella Putra | Friday, September 21 2018 - 17:30 IWST

Menteri Koordinator Bidang Perekonomian Darmin Nasution
Menteri Koordinator Bidang Perekonomian Darmin Nasution

INDUSTRY.co.id - Jakarta - Indonesia Food Watch opens a voice related to the current polemic on rice imports so that there is a pro contra of import policy. Moreover, recently the Coordinating Minister for Economic Affairs Darmin Nasution made a statement to the public that the rice import polemic was caused by production projection data from the Ministry of Agriculture (Ministry of Agriculture) always missing.

Regarding this, Indonesia Food Watch's National Coordinator, Pri Menix Dey, assessed the statement of the Coordinating Minister for Darmin as an attempt to cover up the mismanagement of rice imports and side with the food mafia. The reason is that, as a senior economist, it is impossible not to understand the process and which institutions are given the authority to process, produce and issue data.

"Maybe Mr. Menko is already senile of data. Since the days of the new order until BPS has been processing and releasing food data. Moreover, the data used as the basis for import policy, "said Pri Menix in Jakarta, Thursday (09/20/2018).

The man who is also a researcher at the Bogor Agricultural Institute's Disaster Study Center (IPB) confirmed by referring to the President's direction that one data and one map be used. Data is coordinated by BPS, so it is very clear that data is not from the Ministry of Agriculture, but one door from BPS.

"As far as I know the Ministry of Agriculture has never processed data. So if the Ministry of Agriculture or the technical ministry submits data, it must be processed data from BPS. All technical ministries must do something like that. We also as observers and researchers are always in the analysis using BPS data, "he said.

Therefore, Pri Menix emphasized the polemics of production data must be observant in seeing the root of the problem and all parties must honestly admit it. That the problem is that BPS has been lying down for three years, because the President's instructions to improve the data have not been completed.

"It's actually strange if the import policy is not exactly what the data misleads. The data should not be used as a scapegoat, the data is misrepresented will not protest, "he said.

Furthermore, Pri Menix mentioned, the existing production data is the maximum that the government currently has, regardless of its strengths and weaknesses, it must be able to analyze and policy appropriately. That is, to this day there is no better and more complete data than BPS data.

"Please show if someone feels they have better data.”Instead of waiting to improve the food data from 2015 to the present, it's not finished yet," challenged Menix.

"But please also note the KSA method (red. Area sampling frame) that will be released has not solved the problem, there must be weaknesses in its weaknesses. "Don't solve the problem by adding new problems," he pleaded.

However, Pri Menix asserted that production data was clearly surplus, instead taking import policy. Evidently, the impact is just now.

"Prices remain high on the market, even though there are many productions, excess supply, the main market stock is above 48,000 tons, 2 to 3 times more than last year, the bulog stock is now 2.3 million tons enough until June 2019," he said.

"So if you look at this it should be addressed by the trade system and the trade in rice. It seems that the policy of importing rice is like wrong therapy treating problems. "The headache is thinking how come the rice is given a medicine," he concluded.

News Comment

Today's Industry

Widodo Sucipto, President Director of PT Hydrotech Metal Indonesia.

Selasa, 19 Oktober 2021 - 15:47 WIB

Hydrotech Metal are Getting Closer to Canada Securities Exchange

PT Hydrotech Metal Indonesia are getting closer to Canada Securities Exchange, after the signing of Share Exchange Agreement with a Canadian company recently. The signing was done virtually…

Vice President Ma’ruf Amin and his spouse Ibu Wury head to Ambon for a working visit, Wednesday (13/10). (Photo by: Vice Presidential Secretariat)

Jumat, 15 Oktober 2021 - 22:10 WIB

VP Ma’ruf Amin to Close 20th PON in Papua

Vice President Ma’ruf Amin, on Friday (15/10), is scheduled to close the 20th National Sports Week (PON) in Papua at the Lukas Enembe Stadium, Jayapura regency. The Vice President, his spouse…

President Joko Widodo and Cabinet Secretary Pramono Anung at Kompas Bajo, Puncak Waringin, Thursday (14/10) afternoon. (Photo by: BPMI/Laily Rachev)

Jumat, 15 Oktober 2021 - 21:32 WIB

President Jokowi Visits Kompas Bajo Creative Hub

Ending his working visit in East Nusa Tenggara Province, President Joko “Jokowi” Widodo and First Lady Ibu Iriana on Thursday (14/10) afternoon took a walk to Kompas Bajo which is located…

President Joko Widodo inaugurates Waringin Peak and Batu Cermin tourism area arrangements and eight road segments in Labuan Bajo, East Nusa Tenggara province, Thursday (14/10). (Photo by: PR of Cabinet Secretariat/Rahmat)

Jumat, 15 Oktober 2021 - 20:30 WIB

President Jokowi Inaugurates Area Arrangements in Labuan Bajo

President Joko “Jokowi” Widodo, Thursday (14/10), inaugurated Waringin Peak and Batu Cermin tourism area arrangements and eight road segments at Waringin Peak, Labuan Bajo village, Komodo…

The Integrated Coordination Meeting on the Acceleration of Welfare Development in Papua and West Papua, at the West Papua Governor’s Office Complex, Manokwari, West Papua, Thursday (14/10). (Photo by: BPMI of Vice Presidential Secretariat)

Jumat, 15 Oktober 2021 - 19:30 WIB

VP Ma’ruf Amin Leads Meeting on Welfare Development in Papua, West Papua

Vice President Ma’ruf Amin Thursday (14/10) at West Papua Governor’s Office Complex, Manokwari in West Papua province, led an integrated coordination meeting discussing measures on the acceleration…