The Obligation of Garlic Planting Hindered Land Limitations

By : Dina Astria And Aldo Bella Putra | Wednesday, March 07 2018 - 21:00 IWST

Bawang Putih (ist)
Bawang Putih (ist) - Jakarta - The obligation to grow garlic for the importers of commodities is considered ineffective in maintaining domestic garlic stock because it is hampered by limited land to meet local market needs.

Head of Research Center for Indonesian Policy Studies (CIPS) Hizkia Respatiadi in Jakarta, Tuesday (6/3/2018) said tens of thousands of garlic fields have now been switched to other crops, which coincide with the number of garlic farmers who switch to other plants.

According to Hizkia Respatiadi, garlic land is currently estimated at about 2,000 hectares.

"The function of garlic land has been happening in many places, besides the narrowing of agricultural land, soil fertility in Indonesia is also declining. This condition is one of many causes of self-sufficiency target becomes irrational," he explained.

In addition, he said, it is mandatory that garlic importers to plant garlic are feared to have a negative impact on consumers because it will make the importers spend extra costs.

This extra cost is feared that Hezekiah will have an impact on the selling price of garlic to the public.

"The government should not punish importers because they are just following the needs of the market, they certainly do not want to bear more 'cost' with this obligation.This will have an impact on the selling price, again the disadvantaged communities," Hizkia explained.

Furthermore, Hizkia stated that the government's garlic self-sufficiency target is also not paying attention to the condition of farmers. In fact, he continued, onion farmers are faced with more and more challenges to produce a good onion.

Meanwhile, the Indonesian Farmers Community Forum (Fortani) assesses the obligation of importers to grow garlic as much as five percent of the volume of imports is only a mere formality.

Chief of Farmers Empowerment Division Fortani Pieter Tangka in his statement in Jakarta on Thursday (15/2) said that the regulation tends to be a formality because of the constraints of land and garlic seeds.

According to Pieter Tangka to media crews, the planting of garlic that must be on land above 1,000 meters of land surface is difficult because of the limited location and the potential to cause erosion in the highlands.

Earlier, Police Head of Food Inspection Unit Inspector General Setyo Wasisto said that it will review the Regulation of the Minister of Agriculture which requires the importers to plant garlic as much as five percent of the total import quota.

"We will check it to Kementan because if it is burdensome to the entrepreneurs who want to import and eventually they do not want to import, there will be no goods," said Inspector General Setyo at Police Headquarters, Jakarta, Monday (12/2).

Minister of Agriculture Amran Sulaiman in a number of occasions stated that he is very confident that garlic self-sufficiency target can be achieved in 2019.

News Comment

Today's Industry

Chevron SG Chairman Law Tat Win Credit: Chevron

Rabu, 07 Desember 2022 - 19:44 WIB

What hinders manufacturing firms from lowering their carbon footprint

Chevron Singapore Country Chairman Law Tat Win said the right policies and partnerships are needed for a cleaner energy shift.

Gojek Used for Transportation and Logistics in Indonesia. (Photo:

Rabu, 07 Desember 2022 - 18:48 WIB

Gojek Most Used for Transportation and Logistics in Indonesia

The latest study done by the economic research center Institute for Development of Economics and Finance (Indef) found Gojek to be the most used application (app) for transportation and logistics…

PT Sariguna Primatirta Tbk (Tanobel Group)

Rabu, 07 Desember 2022 - 15:30 WIB

Expand Aggressively, CLEO To Builds 3 New Plants and Develops Distribution Network in 2023

PT Sariguna Primatirta Tbk (Tanobel Group), a listed company, manufacturer of Bottled Drinking Water (AMDK) with the IDX ticker code: CLEO: IJ, will continue the Company's aggressive expansion…

Asahi Kasei Europe GmbH

Rabu, 07 Desember 2022 - 14:15 WIB

Asahi Kasei Participates in Investment in Circularise

Asahi Kasei has decided to invest in Circularise B.V., a startup company in the Netherlands that provides digital product passports and mass balance bookkeeping software, together with Brightlands…

(Photo: © 2022 KRAIBURG TPE)

Rabu, 07 Desember 2022 - 13:18 WIB

KRAIBURG TPE THERMOLAST® H TPE For Medical Valve Applications.

Medical valves control or deliver fluids (liquids and gases) and are essential in operating rooms, intensive care units, outpatient facilities, laboratories, and even homecare settings.