Expertise of Expert Forest Fire Experts at the Ministry of LHK is doubtful

By : Herry Barus And Aldo Bella Putra | Thursday, November 30 2017 - 17:00 IWST

Kebakaran Hutan
Kebakaran Hutan

INDUSTRY.co.id - Jakarta - The question of the expertise of witnesses of the Ministry of Environment and Forestry (LHK) in cases of forest and land fires (karhutla) surfaced after the disclosure of the use of invalid data in the trial process.

"If the data is incorrect, it is clear that expert expertise of the Ministry of LHK needs to be questioned," said environmental law expert Dr. Sadino told reporters in Jakarta, Wednesday (29/11/2017).

Sadino, who is also the Executive Director of the Forest Law and Policy Consultation Bureau, responded to the results of a civil lawsuit filed by PT Jatim Jaya Perkasa (JJP) to Basuki Wasis at the Cibinong District Court, Bogor, West Java.

In his lawsuit, PT JJP assess Basuki Wasis has committed acts against the law. In addition, the table on the test of burnt-out soil published by the Forest Ecology Conservation Laboratory of the Silviculture Department of the Faculty of Forestry IPB, dated November 18, 2013 and Certificate of Experts for the case of environmental destruction through the burning at PT JJP, Rokan Hlir Regency, Riau on December 12, 2013 signed by Basuki Wasis is legally flawed and has no evidentiary and nullified power.

PT JJP also sued Basuki Wasis for compensation of Rp 610 billion. In addition PT JJP sued Basuki Wasis to pay Rp10 million of forced money per day if negligent in executing court decision.

Sadino explained that the disclosure of invalid data makes PT JJP able to file further legal proceedings for the case currently facing. Moreover, the testimony of Basuki Wasis and the data he presented became one of the determinants of the verdict handed down to PT JJP on the lawsuit filed by the Ministry of LHK.

"PT JJP can file an appeal to the Supreme Court," he said as quoted from a press release received by the Editor, Thursday (30/11/2017)

Previously on the lawsuit filed by the Ministry of LHK, PT JJP was fined Rp1 billion by the Rokan Hllir District Court for the fire that occurred in his garden (12/7/2017).

In the same case, the Jakarta High Court also granted an appeal against a civil case filed by the Ministry of LHK to PT JJP to pay compensation and land restitution costs totaling Rp491 billion, in May 2017. In that case one of the expert witnesses is submitted by the Ministry of LHK Basuki Wasis.

Sadino revealed that the disclosure of invalid data by Basuki Wasis is also an opportunity to make further legal proceedings for a number of companies that were previously sued by the Ministry of LHK and convicted of causing karhutla.

News Comment

Today's Industry

Vice President Ma’ruf Amin and his spouse Ibu Wury head to Ambon for a working visit, Wednesday (13/10). (Photo by: Vice Presidential Secretariat)

Jumat, 15 Oktober 2021 - 22:10 WIB

VP Ma’ruf Amin to Close 20th PON in Papua

Vice President Ma’ruf Amin, on Friday (15/10), is scheduled to close the 20th National Sports Week (PON) in Papua at the Lukas Enembe Stadium, Jayapura regency. The Vice President, his spouse…

President Joko Widodo and Cabinet Secretary Pramono Anung at Kompas Bajo, Puncak Waringin, Thursday (14/10) afternoon. (Photo by: BPMI/Laily Rachev)

Jumat, 15 Oktober 2021 - 21:32 WIB

President Jokowi Visits Kompas Bajo Creative Hub

Ending his working visit in East Nusa Tenggara Province, President Joko “Jokowi” Widodo and First Lady Ibu Iriana on Thursday (14/10) afternoon took a walk to Kompas Bajo which is located…

President Joko Widodo inaugurates Waringin Peak and Batu Cermin tourism area arrangements and eight road segments in Labuan Bajo, East Nusa Tenggara province, Thursday (14/10). (Photo by: PR of Cabinet Secretariat/Rahmat)

Jumat, 15 Oktober 2021 - 20:30 WIB

President Jokowi Inaugurates Area Arrangements in Labuan Bajo

President Joko “Jokowi” Widodo, Thursday (14/10), inaugurated Waringin Peak and Batu Cermin tourism area arrangements and eight road segments at Waringin Peak, Labuan Bajo village, Komodo…

The Integrated Coordination Meeting on the Acceleration of Welfare Development in Papua and West Papua, at the West Papua Governor’s Office Complex, Manokwari, West Papua, Thursday (14/10). (Photo by: BPMI of Vice Presidential Secretariat)

Jumat, 15 Oktober 2021 - 19:30 WIB

VP Ma’ruf Amin Leads Meeting on Welfare Development in Papua, West Papua

Vice President Ma’ruf Amin Thursday (14/10) at West Papua Governor’s Office Complex, Manokwari in West Papua province, led an integrated coordination meeting discussing measures on the acceleration…

President Jokowi officially inaugurates Wae Kelambu Multipurpose Terminal, West Manggarai regency, Thursday (14/10).

Jumat, 15 Oktober 2021 - 19:00 WIB

President Jokowi Inaugurates Wae Kelambu Multipurpose Terminal to Support Labuan Bajo Tourist Destination

In a series of his working visit to East Nusa Tenggara province, President Joko “Jokowi” Widodo, Thursday (14/10), inaugurated the Wae Kelambu Multipurpose Terminal, Labuan Bajo Seaport…